LOCATION INFO_New Garden

If you’re searching for great pizza in Greensboro, we invite you to visit Mario’s Pizza on New Garden Road. We’re proud to serve authentic NY–style pizza with huge slices, bold flavor, and fresh ingredients. Our New Garden location is a go-to spot for locals. It provides consistent quality, generous portions, and a laid-back neighborhood feel.

Whether you’re stopping in for lunch or picking up dinner for the family, we have pizza Greensboro residents love. We’re here to serve you with friendly service and food you can count on.

Have questions or ready to order? Give us a call at (336) 316-1119 and our team will be happy to help. Better yet, visit us at 1575 New Garden Road in Greensboro.

We focus on doing things the right way. Our NY–style pizza features a thin, foldable crust with the perfect balance of crisp and chew. Each slice or pie is topped with rich sauce and high-quality cheese. We offer classic and specialty pizzas made fresh to order. Plus, our restaurant has a welcoming environment where everyone feels comfortable. That dedication to flavor and service is why so many guests choose us when they’re craving pizza in Greensboro.

Our Menu Favorites

While our pizza is what we’re best known for, our menu offers something for everyone. It includes everything from Italian comfort food to hearty subs and shareable appetizers. We make it easy to build a meal that satisfies the whole table.

Our NY–style pizza is the foundation of everything we do. We make our dough fresh and bake our pies to deliver large, foldable slices with classic flavor. Choose from traditional favorites like cheese and pepperoni or build a specialty pizza loaded with your favorite toppings. Our pizza always delivers the bold taste and generous portions Greensboro expects.

Speaking of pizza, we also have some of the best stromboli’s and calzones in Greensboro as well. Our chefs make these masterpieces from scratch as well so you’re always guaranteed some of the freshest food in town!

When you’re craving something warm and filling, our Italian entrees hit the spot. We serve baked ziti, lasagna, chicken parmigiana, eggplant parmigiana, spaghetti with marinara, and stuffed ravioli. They are all prepared with rich sauces and classic recipes. These dishes are perfect for a sit-down meal or pairing with pizza for a complete Italian dinner.

Hearty Sub Sandwiches

Our subs are big, flavorful, and made to satisfy. We offer steak, grilled chicken, Chick-O-Philly, sausage, meatball parmigiana, Italian, turkey, and veggie subs. Each is served hot and loaded with toppings. You can order your sub the Mario’s Way or customize it the way you like it.

Appetizers & Desserts

Start your meal with a mouthwatering appetizer. Options include garlic knots, mozzarella sticks, toasted ravioli, fried mushrooms, jalapeño poppers, wings, onion rings, and fries. These shareable favorites are perfect for the table or to complement your pizza. For dessert, we serve classic Italian sweets like cannoli or tiramisu to finish your meal on a sweet note.

We’re proud to be a family-friendly restaurant where everyone feels welcome. Our laid-back environment makes it easy for families to relax and enjoy a meal together. We also offer an extensive Kids Menu with affordable options that parents appreciate and kids love. Consequently, this makes Mario’s Pizza a go-to spot for family dinners.

We’re grateful for the feedback we receive from guests at our New Garden Road location. Many reviews highlight our large slices, authentic New York flavor, friendly staff, and consistent quality. Hearing that families and locals rely on us for dependable pizza in Greensboro motivates us to keep delivering great food every day.

“I am from NY and I can tell you this pizza is darn good. Get it while its hot! So eating there would be best. We got that super large one. Brought it home. Thought we would have pizza for the week. It was all gone. That good!” – 5 Star Review from Bo P.

“Wow! Just wow! Not a local but was doing some work in the area when I happened to come check it out. I walked in and the smell was amazing. So I just had to grab the rest of my family and come back! We tried the boneless sweet chilli wings, the cheese steak Mario’s way and a slice of pepperoni. We recommend it 10/10!!!! Please come try it, you won’t be disappointed.” – 5 Star Review from Kristen R.

“Food was great and affordable. Gloria was very friendly in getting us checked out. Booths and bathrooms were clean! Our family would go again!” – 5 Star Review from Brianna C.

Before you visit, here are a few common questions we hear from guests in the Greensboro area. If you have more questions give us a call at (336) 316-1119. Our team is happy to help.

Do you offer takeout and pickup orders?

Yes, we offer convenient takeout and pickup. Therefore, you can enjoy your favorite dishes at home, at work, or on the go. For takeout, simply click the green button that says, ‘Order In-Store Pickup’. Whereas for delivery, click the red button that says, ‘Order Doordash delivery’. This will take you to our partner page on Doordash to place a delivery order.

Does Mario’s Pizza have a loyalty or rewards program?

Of course! We greatly value our guests and want to ensure they know that! Therefore, we offer a loyalty program that rewards you for ordering your favorite food. Guests earn rewards, special offers, and exclusive deals by ordering through our official app. The app is available on both Android and iPhones.

Can you accommodate large orders or group meals?

Absolutely. Our large pizzas and wide menu selection make us a great option for parties, meetings, and family gatherings. We recommend our huge 24” pizza for parties and gatherings. Plus, we offer party trays on a variety of our dishes from a lasagna tray to a cannoli tray.

Do you offer vegetarian menu options?

Yes, we offer several vegetarian-friendly choices, including cheese and veggie pizzas, pasta dishes, salads, and meat-free appetizers. We even have vegan cheese. For our gluten-free friends, we have gluten-free and cauliflower crusts. Please note, we do have gluten in our kitchen but do our best to stop cross-contamination.

Are your portions good for sharing?

Definitely. Our pizzas, subs, and appetizers are known for generous portions that are perfect for sharing with family and friends.

Greensboro is home to more than 300,000 residents. We’re proud to serve a community that values good food, local flavor, and dependable quality. At Mario’s Pizza, we serve authentic NY–style pizza with huge slices, bold flavor, and fresh ingredients made to order. This makes our New Garden location a go-to spot for locals who want generous portions and a laid-back neighborhood feel.

These local spots are perfect to explore before or after enjoying pizza on New Garden Road.

1. Greensboro Science Center

Combining a zoo, aquarium, and hands-on science museum, the Greensboro Science Center offers an engaging experience for all ages. It’s one of the city’s most popular attractions. This is a great stop for families looking to mix education with fun.

2. Tanger Family Bicentennial Garden

This beautifully maintained garden features walking paths, fountains, sculptures, and seasonal blooms. It’s a peaceful spot for a stroll, photos, or simply enjoying some fresh air just minutes from our location.

3. Guilford Courthouse National Military Park

History comes to life at this Revolutionary War site, where visitors can explore scenic trails, monuments, and educational exhibits. The park offers a blend of outdoor recreation and local heritage in a natural setting.

4. Greensboro Coliseum Complex

Home to concerts, sporting events, and community gatherings, the Greensboro Coliseum Complex is one of the region’s top entertainment destinations. Whether you’re attending a show or a tournament, Mario’s is a popular place to grab a meal first or after.

5. The Bog Garden at Benjamin Park

Known for its elevated boardwalks and lush wetlands, the Bog Garden provides a quiet escape within the city. Visitors can enjoy scenic views, wildlife sightings, and a relaxing walk through this unique natural area.

When you’re craving pizza in Greensboro, we believe Mario’s Pizza on New Garden Road is the best! That’s because we deliver the flavor, portions, and comfort you’re looking for in every meal. From NY–style pizza and Italian classics to hearty subs, appetizers, and family-friendly dining, we remain a local favorite.

Visit us at 1575 New Garden Rd, Greensboro, NC 27410 today. Or call (336) 316-1119 to place an order or ask about our menu. We look forward to serving you and your family soon!

Stop in today for huge flavor, friendly service, and the best NY-style slices in town!