When searching for pizzerias, you may encounter the term Brooklyn style crust. Although you’ve heard of NY and Chicago, this kind is a new one.  Thus, you may be wondering, what is Brooklyn style crust that some restaurants offer?

What Is Brooklyn Style Crust?

When Italian immigrants arrived in America bringing pizza, most people viewed it as an ethnic food. Decades later, GIs returning from the war sought some of the delicious pizza they ate abroad.  Thus, in the mid-1900s, pizzerias started to open up all over the United States.

As Americans fell in love with pizza, some chefs tweaked the original recipe to build a better pie. Examples of this are the deep dish crust and the use of different cheese toppings like Provel.  However, Americans continued to prefer NY style over all the others.

One midwestern pizzeria wanted to capitalize on the appeal of NY pizza. With its roots planted in Michigan, Domino’s offered a thin crust pizza that was different from the traditional NY style.  In 2006, Domino’s Pizza introduced its Brooklyn style crust to differentiate it from the other styles the company offered.  Then, in the spring of 2024, Domino’s rebranded its Brooklyn style to NY style pizza crust. Thus, it appears that the company used this term more as a marketing tactic than a truly different style.

Brooklyn Vs. NY Style Pizza Crust

So, exactly what is Brooklyn style crust? Most pizzerias refer to this as simply NY style and you can use the terms interchangeably. However, you’ll find some crucial differences between Domino’s and an authentic NY pizzeria like Mario’s Pizza.

Nevertheless, it’s important to note that Domino’s Pizza offers several different types of crusts. For our comparison, we used their branded NY style crust.

To begin with, Domino’s Pizza chefs stretch the dough rather than hand toss it. They also dust their crust with cornstarch to make it crispier, something NY pizza makers don’t do. Furthermore, Domino’s tops their pies with a mozzarella and provolone blend for a creamier texture. Finally, Domino’s bakes their pies on metal trays using conveyor belt ovens.

Comparatively, chefs at authentic NY style Italian restaurants like Mario’s Pizza follow traditional methods. For example, we hand toss dough to allow some of the moisture to remain. This gives the crust a softer, chewier finished product. Plus, Mario’s only uses low-moisture mozzarella for its cheese topping. Lastly, we use a wooden peel to place our pies on the floor of our shelf ovens. This bakes our pies to the perfectly golden brown, crispy crust you expect.

How Does Mario’s Compare To Other Local Pizzerias?

In the Piedmont area, you’ll find Pizza Hut, Papa Johns, and Marcos in addition to Domino’s. However, Mario’s Pizza sets itself apart from these pizzerias by offering the following attributes:

  1. Several Convenient Locations
  • 2205 Cloverdale Avenue Northwest, Winston-Salem
  • 1066 Hanes Mall Blvd., Winston-Salem
  • 266 Harvey St., Winston-Salem
  • 4215 W Wendover Ave., Greensboro
  • 1575 New Garden Rd., Greensboro
  • 3354 W. Friendly Ave., Suite 142, Greensboro
  • 1469 River Ridge Dr., Clemmons
  • 2645 N. Main Street, High Point
  • 5824 Samet Drive, High Point
  1. Extensive Menu

While some pizzerias only offer pizza and a few appetizers, we offer an extensive menu. It includes appetizers, salads, subs, calzones, strombolis, Italian entrees, and desserts.

  1. Multiple Dining Choices

Do you feel like getting out of the house for dinner? Perhaps you would prefer your meal delivered to your home or picked up on the way home from the office. Whichever option you want, Mario’s Pizza has you covered.

  1. Affordable Meal Choices

As part of a large Italian family, our owners understand the expense of taking a family out to dinner. Thus, our commitment has always aimed to serve families:

  • Low prices
  • Huge portions
  • Daily specials
  • Kids’ menu
  1. Positive reviews

Many people love our food. Here’s what a couple have to say about Mario’s Pizza:

We get carry out pizza from Mario’s on Cloverdale Ave in WS regularly. It is GREAT! The cannolis are fantastic too. And the people who work there are the nicest. Love it! – Mary K. Winston Salem

Mario’s has the best pizza in Winston-Salem, NC hands down. The crust is always perfectly crisp and all the toppings you add are plentiful. The flavor is superb. — Fran G. Winston Salem

FAQs About Mario’s Pizza

Have we thoroughly explained what is Brooklyn style crust? Below, we answer a few more questions about our delicious food.

Does Your Menu Have Gluten Free Options?

We offer rice-based and cauliflower pizza crusts and many of our pizza toppings are also gluten free. You’ll also find several fresh salads on our menu. Furthermore, let your server know of your food restrictions when you order and we’ll do our best to accommodate you. However, we only have one kitchen and the risk of cross-contamination exists.

Can You Provide Food For My Next Event?

Of course! We offer several pizza sizes as well as party trays that you can pick up to serve to your guests. Moreover, with advance notice, we can accommodate any special needs.  We request that you call your nearest Mario’s Pizza several days before the event to discuss the details.

Do You Offer A Rewards Program?

Yes! When you join our loyalty program, you can earn points toward free food!  Plus, our program has special perks like a free slice of pizza for joining and a gift on your birthday. Just let your server know the next time you order or download our app.

Is your mouth watering for delicious pizza? Why not call your nearest Mario’s Pizza for some fabulous NY style pizza?

Thin, thick, stuffed, or deep dish crust, Americans love their pizza. As a mealtime essential in many households, most people eat pizza at least once a week. Moreover, as statistics show, most people prefer NY style over others. Yet, finding great-tasting NY style pizza outside of Manhattan isn’t always easy. If you’re looking for the best NY style pizza near me, visit Mario’s Pizza. We have multiple locations throughout the Triad in Greensboro, Winston-Salem, Clemmons and High Point.

Some Of The Many Styles Of Pizza

Are pizzas really that different? We’ll let you decide as we examine some of the most popular kinds:

1. Neapolitan

The grandfather of all pizza, Neapolitan traces its history back to Naples, Italy. It was during the 18th century when Italians began topping traditional flatbread with tomatoes. One baker, Raffaele Esposito, also added mozzarella and basil creating the first pizza.

2. NY Style

At the turn of the century, approximately two million Italians emigrated to America, many settling in New York City. Although these immigrants brought their recipes from the old country, sometimes they tweaked them to meet new demands.

During this time in history, workers needed cheap, transportable food. Typically, traditional Neapolitan pizza tends to be soft in the middle, often requiring a fork and knife to eat. With a few changes, pizza became foldable with a crispy outer crust. This new kind of pizza quickly became popular due to its portability and price.

3. Chicago Style

The year was 1943 when two entrepreneurs opened a restaurant, Pizzeria Uno, in Chicago. Owners, Ike Sewell and Richard Ricardo Sr., served a new kind of pizza, deep dish.

Featuring a thick pizza crust with the ingredients in reverse, the pizza became an immediate hit. Deep dish pizza has layers of mozzarella cheese, toppings, and then crushed tomatoes on top.

4. Detroit Pizza

Another style of deep dish pizza became popular in Detroit in 1946. Tavern owner Gus Guerra abandoned the idea that pizzas must be round. Instead, he used square pans and a different kind of pizza cheese, Wisconsin brick. The mild and sweet flavor of the cheese and soft, airy square crust, combined to create a new favorite.

5. St. Louis Pizza

Also around the same time as Chicago and Detroit pizza emerged, St. Louis restaurateur Amedeo Fiore introduced his version. Discarding the use of yeast in the dough, this pizza crust has a cracker-like consistency. Moreover, St. Louis style pizza uses a unique blend of cheeses particular to the area, Provel. A gooey combination of white cheddar, Swiss, and provolone, Provel lends a sharp flavor with smoky undertones.

Characteristics Of The Best NY Style Pizza Near Me

Most people agree that NY style pizza is their favorite. Unfortunately, many restaurants fall short of copying the exact combination of factors to create the perfect slice. Often, making this masterpiece is a puzzle that has taken on mythical proportions. From the speculation of something in the water to the ovens, critics have sought the problems associated with subpar pizza.

Generally, NY style pizza has a thin crust with a crunch and chewiness without being too doughy. The crust must be flexible enough that you can fold it in half. To achieve this consistency, chefs use high-protein flour with extra olive oil and sugar. Furthermore, pizza chefs always hand-toss the dough.

Usually, the sauce has onions, garlic, basil, and oregano instead of crushed tomatoes. Additionally, you must use shredded, low-moisture mozzarella for the pizza cheese.

Even baking requires special instructions because the oven temperature will affect the taste and texture of your crust. NY style pizza requires a very hot oven for its signature flavor and texture.

Best NY style Pizza Near Me FAQs

You may think finding great tasting pizza in North Carolina is impossible. However, when looking for the best NY style pizza near me, visit Mario’s Pizza. If you’ve never stopped by, you may not be familiar with our menu and service. Thus, below, we’ve answered a few commonly asked questions.

What Makes Your Pizza Authentic NY Style?

Raised in Brooklyn, NY, brothers Vinny, Tony, and Mario can trace their ancestry back to Calabria, Italy. Additionally, our dedication to creating delicious, authentic NY style pizza is backed by our customer reviews:

I was raised in New York and loved the pizza from there. When I relocated to NC I was missing my NY pizza, till I discovered Mario’s. Mario’s Pizza is exactly NY Pizza. I no longer missed my NY Pizza from New York. Mario’s takes a lot of care in the Pizza they make from the dough to the toppings. It’s fresh, its delicious and it’s satisfying. It’s Pizza made with love. The entire menu is something to rave about. Everything they serve is made to perfection. Hands down Mario’s is the best!! – Chris “Christine” R

Hands down, the best pizza in Greensboro, especially if you’re a NYer at heart. The slices are HUGE and sooooo good! – Jacqui H.

Do You Make Vegan Or Gluten Free Pizza?

We offer both a gluten free pizza and a cauliflower crust pizza with an option for vegan cheese. Plus, we can prepare salads to meet your dietary restrictions. Just let your server know of your special request when you place your order.

Of course, we take all dietary restrictions very seriously. However, for those patrons who experience severe reactions, we do only have one kitchen to prepare all our food.

Can I Buy A Gift Certificate For Mario’s Pizza?

You can give the gift of delicious Italian food! Mario’s Pizza gift cards make great presents for birthdays, holidays, and other special occasions. Moreover, you can buy them in any amount. Stop by any one of our convenient locations or purchase a gift card from our app today!

Speaking of gift cards, if you purchase one by December 23rd, 2022, you get a free 6-Piece of our tasty Garlic Knots!

Pizza ranks as the second most popular fast food in America behind hamburgers. Its crispy crust, tangy sauce, and gooey cheese combination are irresistible. Yet, with so many pizzerias around town, which is the best pizza High Point has to offer?

Necessary Qualities For A Great Pizzeria

While you might find dozens of pizzerias in your town, not all create the slice of heaven you crave. Moreover, the style of pizza is almost as varied as the toppings. Yet, whether you want NY style, Chicago deep dish, or Sicilian style, popular Italian restaurants have similar characteristics:

1. Great Reviews From Customers

The best way to find delicious pizza is to search for reviews from customers. At Mario’s Pizza, we have a loyal fan base who love to tell others about our pizza:

“The staff, the food omg I love this place and refuse to get pizza anywhere else. If you want pizza you come here.” – Mike Smith

“Excellent pizza, as someone from the Philly/NJ/NYC area born and raised but now in Western PA (where great pizza is lacking), I’m picky about my pizza and know what I’m looking for in quality. I was VERY happy and impressed with Mario’s just regular cheese pizza. Loved it, as good as I’ve maybe had in the past few years. Keep up the great work! (Also we used Door Dash and everything went well).” – Gavin Hoban

2. Great Menu Options

While we specialize in delicious pizza, we also offer many other tasty Italian dishes including subs, calzones, stromboli, and parmigiana. Plus, we offer over a dozen appetizers, salads, and delectable desserts.

3. Delicious Food at Reasonable Prices

Generally, great Italian cuisine begins with family recipes from the old country. Of course, Mario’s dishes trace their roots back to Calabria, Italy.

However, we also recognize the importance of value and being able to take your family out to dinner. That’s why we offer a kid’s menu with options for $5 and under along with daily specials.

4. Online Ordering

Americans lead very busy lives. Ordering online offers the convenience of having food ready when you need it. Of course, Mario’s offers this accommodation at all our locations. You can choose to pick it up or have it delivered to your door. Either way, you’ll save time and have a tasty meal.

Essential Qualities For The Best Tasting Pizza

While the pizzeria’s qualities are important, it’s time to talk about the best pizza High Point has to offer. What makes one restaurant’s pizza superior to another? Below, we outline the required features of the best tasting pizza.

1. Fresh Ingredients

Undoubtedly, you can taste the difference between fresh and preserved ingredients. Canning and processing companies use sodium, sugar, and preservatives to increase the shelf-life of food. However, these additives mask the true flavor of the substance. Of course, at Mario’s we use the freshest ingredients possible.

2. Amazing Pizza Crust

Even if the rest of your pie is superb, a soggy, tasteless crust will ruin it. Whether you like it thin or thick, the best pizza begins with the crust. Three characteristics make the perfect crust:

  • Texture
  • Thickness
  • Flavor

3. Mouthwatering Sauce

If the crust is the base of your pizza, the sauce is the enhancer. With the taste of fresh tomatoes perfectly seasoned, the sauce improves the overall flavor of the pie.

4. Perfect Combination Of Toppings

Usually, pizza lovers will hotly debate which toppings make the best pizza. However, whichever combination you prefer, the best pizzerias will offer plenty of options. Here at Mario’s Pizza, we have over 20 regular and premium toppings designed to make your pizza memorable.

5. Cooked To Perfection

Wood-fired or gas oven? Typically, each way of baking may impart a slightly different flavor. However, great pizza chefs also pay attention to oven temperature and cooking time to produce the perfect pie. Never soggy, undercooked, or dry, a great pizza is a delicacy to savor.

6. Tastes Delicious

Of course, when you put all these qualities together, you should end up with a pizza that tastes delicious.

Best Pizza High Point- Mario’s FAQs

We’d love to answer any questions you may have about the best pizza High Point has to offer. Below, we’ve answered a few of our most commonly asked questions.

Do You Have Gluten-Free Pizza?

Yes, we do! You can choose from our more traditional rice-based or cauliflower crusts. Additionally, many of our toppings are gluten-free. Ask your server about safe options when you place your order.

Do You Offer Special Deals?

Of course! You’ll find our daily specials listed on our website. Moreover, we invite you to join our loyalty program. It’s easy to become a member! You download the app from our website or just let your server know the next time you place an order.

Earn 1 point for every $2 you spend doing what you love, eating pizza! Then, start enjoying your rewards! You can get free food, cashback, and special offers. Plus, we have double point days and rewards for social sharing. We’ll even send you a gift on your birthday.

Where Can I Find Mario’s Pizza?

In High Point, you’ll find Mario’s Pizza at:

  • 2645 North Main Street
  • 5824 Samet Drive

While in Winston Salem, you’ll find us at:

  • 2205 Cloverdale Avenue Northwest
  • 1066 Hanes Mall Boulevard
  • 266 Harvey Street (off Stratford)

We also have a location in Clemmons:

  • 1469 River Ridge Drive

If you’re in Greensboro we’re located on:

  • 4215 W. Wendover Avenue
  • 1575 New Garden Road

Plus, we’re pleased to announce a new location in Greensboro!

  • 3354 W. Friendly Avenue Suite 412

Follow us on Facebook for the announcement of our opening date!