The Best Toppings for Pizza in NC

When you’re searching for the best toppings for pizza, fresh flavors and high-quality ingredients matter most. At Mario’s Pizza, our team believes every pizza is personal. Some of our guests crave classic pepperoni, others love vegetables, and many want to try new pizza topping combinations. Whatever your favorite, we serve authentic NY-style pies that always hit the spot. With our family recipes and generous portions, you’ll taste the difference in every bite. Come visit our team at Mario’s Pizza and discover your new favorite slice.

Classic Toppings That Never Go Out of Style

Certain toppings stand the test of time. These choices have been loved by pizza fans for generations, and for good reason:

• Pepperoni: Our top-seller, featuring a spicy, crisp bite.
• Italian Sausage: Rich, bold, and packed with flavor.
• Mushrooms: Earthy and tender, these pair well with meat or vegetables.
• Green Peppers & Onions: Fresh, sweet, and crunchy, they lighten up any slice.
• Extra Cheese: Because you can never have too much gooey cheese.

Every day, our team preps these ingredients for maximum freshness. We always pile them high for a delicious, classic experience.

Specialty Options: Unique Toppings and Combinations

Looking for something new? We offer creative flavors for adventurous eaters and pizza lovers ready to branch out. Our specialty pizzas feature bold combos you won’t find everywhere:

• 5 Boroughs: Ham, bacon, ground beef, sausage, and pepperoni team up for a protein-packed experience.
• The Greenhouse: Spinach, black olives, tomatoes, bell peppers, mushrooms, and banana peppers create a colorful, flavorful bite.
• Pizza Bianco: Creamy ricotta and mozzarella with fresh garlic — no red sauce needed!
• The Worx: A satisfying blend of meats and veggies for those who want it all.
• Spicy Buffalo Chicken: Tender chicken tossed in zesty buffalo sauce, perfect for heat seekers.

Not sure what to try? Our team is always happy to recommend a favorite or help you build your own.

How to Build Your Own Pizza Like a Pro

At Mario’s Pizza, we encourage you to get creative with your pizza. Start by choosing your crust—classic hand-tossed, gluten-free, or even cauliflower. Next, pick your sauce. Love traditional marinara? Prefer creamy white garlic? Want to go sauce-free? The choice is yours!

For toppings, think about how flavors and textures work together. Pair salty meats with fresh veggies for balance, or add banana peppers or jalapeños for a spicy kick. Mix crisp bacon with melty cheese or blend tender spinach with savory sausage. The right combination takes your pizza from good to unforgettable.

What Makes Mario’s Pizza Stand Out?

We take pride in every pizza we make. Our NY-style pies are crafted using family recipes passed down through generations. We prepare fresh dough every day and always use premium toppings. Moreover, we hand toss our NY-style pizza to get the texture just right! Our generous portions mean you get more than just a meal—you get a full experience. Dine in, order takeout, or have your favorite pizza delivered. With nine locations throughout the Triad, we’re always nearby when the craving hits. Plus, with 35-plus toppings, you’re nearly guaranteed to find some of the best toppings for pizza at Mario’s.

Fun Facts About Pizza Toppings

Pizza lets everyone get creative! Here are some fun facts about toppings and pizza trends:

• Some guests mix pineapple with jalapeños or even peanut butter with bacon for a sweet and spicy combo.
• Hawaiian pizza topped with pineapple was actually invented in Canada in the 1960s.
• Vegan cheese and plant-based meats are on the rise, giving more options to meat-free eaters.
• Gourmet toppings like artichokes or truffle oil are popular among foodies.
• Mushrooms are one of the most beloved veggies on pizza across the globe.
• Around the world, you’ll find unique choices like curry chicken or even squid on pizza.

We love seeing what our guests invent, and we’re always here to help you try something new.

Frequently Asked Questions About Pizza Toppings

We often get questions about our menu, the best toppings for pizza, and how to order the perfect pizza. Here are answers to some of the most common questions our customers ask:

What is the most popular pizza topping in the world?

Pepperoni tops the list almost everywhere. Its spicy, crispy edges and rich flavor make it a crowd favorite.

Does Mario’s Pizza offer vegetarian options?

Yes! Our menu features a wide variety of vegetarian toppings, from mushrooms and peppers to black olives, spinach, and tomatoes. The Greenhouse is a popular meatless specialty pizza.

Can I order half-and-half pizzas to try different toppings?

Absolutely. We’re happy to split your pizza down the middle so you can enjoy two different topping combos in one pie.

Are there gluten-free options available?

Yes, we offer gluten-free crust at many locations. Please note, our kitchen prepares foods with gluten, so we can’t guarantee no cross-contact, but we do our best.

Where can I find Mario’s Pizza?

We have nine locations across Greensboro, High Point, Clemmons and Winston-Salem in North Carolina:

• 2205 Cloverdale Ave, Winston-Salem
• 1066 Hanes Mall Blvd, Winston-Salem
• 266 Harvey St, Winston-Salem
• 575 New Garden Rd, Greensboro
• 4215 W Wendover Ave, Greensboro
• 3354 W. Friendly Ave, Suite 142, Greensboro
• 2645 N Main St, High Point
• 5824 Samet Dr, High Point
• 469 River Ridge Dr, Clemmons

Toppings, Taste, and Mario’s Await

At Mario’s Pizza, we know that the best toppings for pizza make every slice memorable. From timeless classics to bold, new combinations, we’re passionate about great ingredients and big flavors. Visit your nearest Mario’s Pizza or order delivery online today to build your perfect pie. For updates and specials, follow us on Facebook and Instagram.